The Legal Examiner Mark The Legal Examiner Mark The Legal Examiner Mark search twitter facebook feed linkedin instagram google-plus avvo phone envelope checkmark mail-reply spinner error close
Skip to main content

An Outer Banks vacation home served as the setting for a nearly fatal drowning on the evening of July 29, 2015. A 3-year-old boy fell into the rental house’s in-deck backyard pool and went undiscovered for an unknown amount of time. As the accompanying picture, taken from the Corolla, North Carolina (NC), property’s website shows, the pool has a fence set many feet back from the water’s edge but no other barriers to entry.
A 3-year-old boy nearly drowned in this unfenced backyard pool at a North Carolina vacation rental home.

News reports indicate that family members performed CPR on the toddler until emergency medical personnel arrived and that the young child was later flown by helicopter to a Norfolk hospital. It remains unknown whether the boy went without air for long enough to sustain permanent brain damage or other lifelong health problems.

Private pools pose the greatest risks for drowning, especially for children too young to know how to swim. Parents must accompany their kids at poolside or in the water at all times to prevent tragedies. No one can remain completely vigilant at all times, however. This makes restricting access to pools as much as possible essential. At a minimum, the Consumer Product Safety Commission recommends, a four-foot-high fence with a locking gate should run around the entire perimeter of any backyard pool.

Builders and homeowners often forgo including that safety feature because such a fence would ruin the look of a deck, patio or yard. Aesthetics should never take precedence over lives.

My Carolina personal injury law firm colleagues and I wish the boy a full and rapid recovery from his near drowning. We also want to take this opportunity to remind property owners and rental home managers that they must do everything they can to ensure the health of their visitors and customers. The legal principal underlying this admonishment is premises liability, which, in layman’s terms means that homeowners and businesses must remove or mitigate as many dangers as can be easily identified. In terms of a vacation house with a pool, doing that entails erecting a fence close enough to the pool that accidental entry becomes unlikely.



  1. Gravatar for Phyllis

    The pool area DOES appear to have a fence surrounding it--the child must have entered from the house area.

  2. Gravatar for Angelina

    This home does have the properly required fence barrier around the entire pool and pool deck area. There are 2 access gates that close and latch automatically when coming or going. There is no entrance from the house. Last sentence of first paragraph is incorrect and should be noted. Number one safety is everyone's concern here in the Outer Banks. There would never be a "CO" given if there was no fence around this or any pools in the Outer Banks.

  3. Gravatar for LOCAL

    First and most importantly, I am very sorry for this families tragedy. I wish the best for a recovery! The picture shows a fence...therefore I am confused. I am also confused as to why "premise liability" needs to even be mentioned in this article! It is not the fences fault, nor the gates fault, nor the homeowners fault, nor the property managers fault, nor the pool boys fault that this child ended up in the water. People need to take responsibility for their actions and stop trying to find blame elsewhere! Again, this family is in my thoughts and this child's recovery is far more important than "implying" it is someone or something's fault other than the people in charge of this child.

Comments are closed.

Of Interest